Skip advert
Advertisement

Honda Civic Type R (FN2) – the car world's greatest misses

Its lineage contains some hot hatch greats, but the late-noughties Civic wasn’t one of them

Honda Civic Type R FN2

It’s a somewhat risky move criticising a Honda with the Type R badge, given the passionate following the red ‘R’ has. When it comes to the Civic, it’s not something I’m usually inclined to do anyway. After all, who doesn’t love the forbidden fruit of the wild EK9, the historical significance of the ubiquitous and beloved EP3, or the class-crushing excellence of first the FK8 and now the FL5?

Advertisement - Article continues below

However, it’s the last of the naturally aspirated Type Rs we need to have a chat about: the FN2. As a final hurrah for the brilliant Honda K20 engine, reworked to provide a more flexible, torquier delivery, this version should by now have taken its place as a solid-gold modern classic. Yet a glance at the classifieds proves this emphatically is not the case. But why?

> Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution 10 – the car world's greatest misses

I can still clearly recall writing the initial road test on the FN2 for a weekly car magazine. There was a lot of excitement surrounding the model at the time. Sure, the styling must have bemused the regular Civic’s elderly core audience, and the interior was plain weird, but the R version had a K20 hooked up to a six-speed manual, plus gorgeous Type R bucket seats too, so really, who cared? There was a deeply troubling line in the press pack though. It read ‘torsion beam rear suspension’, and as anyone who knows Hondas or indeed engineering matters in general can testify, this was fundamentally a retrograde step.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Unlike previous Civic Type Rs, the FN2 was a European model. In Japan, a totally different Type R was now available in the form of the FD2, which had a far more conventional exterior, a more powerful K20 (as usual) and a multi-link rear end (again, as usual). The FN2 was built at Swindon and was exported to various European countries, with the UK being the biggest market. Confusingly, some time after the car’s launch in 2007 it was then sent over to Japan as the ‘Type R Euro’.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Did we obsess too much over that rear beam? After all, what suspension set-up links 205 GTI, Clio Williams and 306 Rallye? Exactly. Yet it’s worth considering that most of those French classics weigh significantly less than a ton; the FN2 hit the scales at 1267kg, and the control needed for a hot hatch while supporting that kind of mass did not make for a comfortable car. Renault Sport just about managed it by the time of the Phase 2 Mégane 250, but even then you’d never class it as having the same ride sophistication as a Mk5 Golf GTI.

That first press-fleet FN2 was ridiculously firm. It hopped, skipped and jumped down a B-road, driving itself and the driver to distraction. It didn’t feel quite as fast as it should have, either. Sure, a widening of the VTEC band helped, but with 198bhp it was no more powerful than the old EP3 despite being a good deal heavier. These days outright speed often seems irrelevant, but back then, with class limits being pushed, the FN2 just felt off the pace. It transpired that the damper settings on the road test car weren’t right (an innocent mix-up or actions with a certain objective?) but drives in later cars revealed a similarly wooden feeling. It just wasn’t that good.

It wasn’t until two generations later, with the 2017 FK8, complete with a multi-link rear once again, that the Type R truly reached for the stars. Maybe it’s just a coincidence…

This story was first featured in evo issue 328.

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Audi RS3 v Toyota GR Yaris v Mercedes-AMG A45 S – car pictures of the week
Hot hatch test
Features

Audi RS3 v Toyota GR Yaris v Mercedes-AMG A45 S – car pictures of the week

In the latest issue of evo, we test three of the most sophisticated hot hatches on sale against each other on road and track – these are our favourite…
29 Mar 2025
Toyota GR Yaris 2025 review – the modern homologation special gets even better
Toyota GR Yaris
In-depth reviews

Toyota GR Yaris 2025 review – the modern homologation special gets even better

Toyota’s GR Yaris was always brilliant but has received a number of key and welcome updates. It’s even better but also, a lot more expensive.
28 Mar 2025
Mercedes-AMG A45 S 2025 review – the ultimate hyperhatch?
Mercedes-AMG A45 S front
In-depth reviews

Mercedes-AMG A45 S 2025 review – the ultimate hyperhatch?

The A45 S packs some of the most impressive numbers seen in a hot hatch, but is it one of the best to drive?
27 Mar 2025
New VW Golf GTI Clubsport S is coming to take on the Honda Civic Type R
Volkswagen Golf GTI GTI Clubsport S
News

New VW Golf GTI Clubsport S is coming to take on the Honda Civic Type R

VW will celebrate 50 years of the Golf GTI at the N24, with the reveal of a very special model
21 Mar 2025
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Performance Link Mazda MX-5 R300 review – an MX-5 with Honda VTEC power
Performance Link Mazda MX-5 R300 – front
Reviews

Performance Link Mazda MX-5 R300 review – an MX-5 with Honda VTEC power

A screaming 296bhp Honda VTEC engine and a full chassis upgrade package turn the NC-generation Mazda MX-5 into something altogether more thrilling
25 Mar 2025
Used car deals of the week
Main used car deals
Advice

Used car deals of the week

In this week’s used car deals, we’ve sourced everything from a Mazda MX-5 to a McLaren 720S
26 Mar 2025
The new Porsche 911 Turbo (992.2) is going electrified, and we've spotted it testing
Porsche 911 Turbo spies
Spy shots

The new Porsche 911 Turbo (992.2) is going electrified, and we've spotted it testing

The 911 Turbo will receive a mid-life refresh later this year, gaining hybrid power for the first time ever. Here's an early look
25 Mar 2025